Posted by Adam Gordon on Nov 11, 2010 in all, managing uncertainty, strategic foresight
I was recently in South Africa where I had a hand in setting up an executive foresight-innovation executive training program to be run in association with the Stanford Center for Foresight and Innovation.
While I was there I couldn’t help noticing the business print and radio waves being dominated by the potential entrance of Wal-Mart, with all the jitters of local businesses considering the knock-ons and side-effects of the “über cost competitor” turning up at the end of the street.
If it goes ahead, Wal-Mart will enter via acquisition of local retailer Massmart which is, as the name suggests, a copy-cat company anyway, so it would seem all there is to talk about is price. As things stand, Wal-Mart is in its fifth week of due diligence on Massmart, currently visiting all 288 stores under acquisition, according to a recent WSJ report.
Now Wal-Mart is not busting a gut for the SA market, population 45 million, of course. The whole project is about using the South African operation as gateway into Africa as a whole. It is bet on the 5-to-10-year-and-beyond future of sub-Saharan Africa.
Massmart Chief Executive Grant Pattison is quoted as saying “you have to take the long view on Africa,” and this is exactly what Wal-Mart is doing. Enacting a long forward play for the newly strengthening African retail market.
Other than inventing the scale-based supply-chain-squeeze model of retail, which must go down as one of the great business innovations of all time, Wal-Mart is hardly known as a foresight-based player. As forward looking as the Massmart acquisition is, Wal-Mart has in fact been well beaten to the African punch by the Chinese who have been investing across the continent over the past decade (although the Chinese investment has been predominantly in infrastructure and resources, while Wal-Mart’s would be in anticipation of lower-middle class consumer enrichment on the back of that.)
The glass half full
The Chinese invasion is by far the biggest thing to happen in African economies since European colonialism, not only due to widespread infrastructural investment, and not only because it comes without “Washington Consensus” strings attached, but, even more fundamentally, because it is driving a zeitgest shift in business confidence. Deep problems remain, but suddenly the glass that was half empty appears half full, particularly to occidentals.
One expression of the new half-full perspective is McKinsey’s breathless report (June 2010) on Africa’s economic emergence, entitled “Lions on the Move,” which starts: “Africa’s collective economy grew very little during the last two decades of the 20th century. But sometime in the late 1990s, the continent began to stir. GDP growth picked up and bounded ahead…”
Asian Tigers. African Lions. Geddit? But when both Wal-Mart and McKinsey are setting their watches to the near-term future African economic growth story, you can bet other companies are set to pounce too.
Posted by Adam Gordon on Dec 23, 2009 in all, history, lifestyles & values, social change, strategic foresight, trend tracking
One of the principles of anticipating the future correctly, separating out what will happen from what we think-hope-fear will happen, is to consciously factor in the principle that fundamental human needs don’t disappear. They are bundled, interpreted, and served one way in the present, and this may change in a new era as technologies advance and relationships and associations change. But needs are forever. And often the future goes ‘backwards’ to old, archetypal models that served needs before.
Witness the uptake of ‘feudal’ protection in a competitive, recessionary marketplace, where Wal-Mart is offering rental space insde a new Chicago store to neighborhood businesses. Apparently tenants already include a dog groomer and a fried chicken outlet, and Wal-Mart is going to be inviting in barbers, manicurists, and other local small businesses.
Regional general manager Rolando Rodriguez told the NY Times: “We want the same resurgence of the community…”.
It’s not all about community of course. Wal-Mart is seeking counter-PR to endemic criticism (and evidence) that their megastores kill mom-and-pop shops on which many local jobs and services depend, and is hoping the gambit will revive its six-year stalled bid for the city’s approval of proposed Chicago stores.
Anyway, as one observer, Marissa Johnson, said of the new arrangement: “It’s like sharecropping.”
Yes, this is the return of a feudal model. The lord owns the land and the small guy works his patch, offering a regular tribute. And small guys will jump at it because — in the absence of fundamental challenge to an iniquitous system — having the protection of a lord is better than not having it.
Another need that’s not going away, merely being reinterpreted (ironically back to pre-feudal organization) is our need to mark the darkest night of the year with ritual. Yule is the pagan winter solstice rite centered on a December 21 dusk-to-dawn vigil. It was absorbed into Christmas and not widely practiced for centuries. But now, as reported in the big UK media Christmas pregame show, there’s been a great surge in Yule festivities and attendance. By how much depends on who is quoted but nobody is denying the trend — which more or less mirrors the decline in formal Christian Christmas (secular, gift-giving, tree decorating Christmas is alive and well.)
The need is a constant. The rituals will change, often mining the past.
read more